Making the Right Choice: Electric vs Stovetop Kettle

The great kettle debate, "Electric vs Stovetop Kettle," has been brewing for years. Each has its unique benefits and drawbacks, but which one is the right fit for your kitchen and coffee needs?

Today we'll explore the ins and outs of these two popular kitchen appliances, comparing efficiency, safety features, material options, aesthetics, and more to help you make an informed decision. You'll be brewing your next fresh cup of Nuddy Coffee in no time!

Short Summary

  • Electric kettles are a popular choice for households due to their speed, convenience and safety features. Stovetop kettles offer traditional charm, higher temperatures & better durability.
  • Electric kettles are more energy efficient than stove top ones but boil water faster. They also have more safety features like auto shut-off & double insulation compared to the latter's heat resistant handles & lid.
  • Electric or stovetop? Pick your kettle based on aesthetics, material options and durability, convenience or even coffee ritual needs!

Understanding Electric Kettles

Electric kettles are the modern world's answer to boiling water. Fueled by electricity, these versatile appliances come with a heating element that quickly and efficiently heats the water inside, making them a popular choice in today's fast-paced world. There's a wide variety of electric kettles available, ranging from simple, budget-friendly options to advanced electric kettles with features like temperature control, auto shut-off, and more.

While electric kettles are known for their speed and convenience, they also tend to be safer than their stovetop counterparts, thanks to features like double insulation and automatic shut-off when the water reaches boiling point. These added safety measures help prevent accidents like burns or water overflowing, making electric kettles a popular choice for many households.

Understanding Stovetop Kettles

Stovetop kettles, on the other hand, are a nod to tradition and simplicity. Designed to be used on a gas or electric stove, these kettles rely on an external heat source to boil water. Although they may lack some of the advanced features found in electric kettles, stovetop kettles are still a popular choice for those who appreciate their vintage charm and the soothing sound of a whistling kettle signalling that the water is ready.

One advantage of stovetop kettles is their ability to reach higher temperatures than most electric kettles, making them ideal for those who prefer their coffee extra hot. Additionally, stovetop kettles are typically more durable and can last for years with proper care, making them a worthwhile investment for some.

Comparing Efficiency: Electric vs Stovetop Kettle

When it comes to efficiency, electric and stovetop kettles both have their strengths and weaknesses. Let's dive deeper into their performance in terms of energy consumption, boiling speed, and overall performance.

Energy Consumption

Electric kettles are championed for their energy efficiency, using less energy than stovetop kettles to boil the same amount of water. This efficiency can be attributed to their heating element, which is designed to handle a high current and convert it directly into heat, making them a more eco-friendly option. In fact, it only costs about two cents to boil water in an electric kettle, which makes your morning cup of coffee taste that much better.

Stovetop kettles, in contrast, require a gas or electric stove to heat the water, making them less efficient in terms of energy consumption. Despite this, they can still be a viable option for those who prefer a traditional kettle or have limited access to electricity.

Boiling Speed

Speed is a major selling point for electric kettles. Thanks to their powerful heating elements, electric kettles can boil water in just a few minutes, making them an ideal choice for busy mornings when you need your coffee stat. The boiling speed of an electric kettle can vary depending on factors like capacity, brand, and age, but typically takes between 100 and 300 seconds to bring water to a boil.

Electric stove top kettle on bench

Stovetop kettles, on the other hand, can take up to 10 minutes to boil water, as they rely on the heat from a gas or electric stove. While this may not be ideal for those in a hurry, some people enjoy the slower pace, as it provides a nostalgic and relaxing ritual to their coffee-making process.


Performance-wise, electric kettles tend to outshine stovetop kettles due to their advanced features, such as automatic shut-off and temperature control. This not only ensures that the water is boiled to the perfect temperature, but also prevents accidents like burns or water overflowing from the kettle. Electric kettles are typically 80-90% efficient when it comes to energy consumption and boiling speed.

Stovetop kettles, while lacking some of the advanced features of electric kettles, can still perform well in terms of boiling water. The main difference in performance between the two lies in the speed and convenience offered by electric kettles, as well as the additional safety features they possess.

Electric stovetop kettle on bench

Safety Features

As mentioned earlier, electric kettles come with a variety of safety features that make them a safer choice compared to stovetop kettles. For instance, electric kettles are equipped with an automatic shut-off feature that turns off the heating element once the water reaches boiling point, preventing accidents like burns or water overflowing. Some electric kettles also have double insulation, ensuring that the exterior remains cool to the touch even while the water inside is boiling.

Stovetop kettles, on the other hand, have fewer safety features. They typically come with heat-resistant handles and a lid to keep the steam inside, but lack the auto shut-off feature found in electric kettles. This means that users must be more vigilant when using a stovetop kettle to ensure that they don't accidentally leave it on the heat source for too long, potentially causing damage to the kettle or even a fire.

Material Options and Durability

Both electric and stovetop kettles come in a range of materials, including stainless steel, borosilicate glass, and plastic. Stainless steel is a popular choice for its durability and ability to heat up quickly, while borosilicate glass offers a more elegant and visually appealing option, allowing you to see the water as it boils. Plastic kettles, while generally less expensive, may not be the best choice for those seeking a long-lasting and healthy option.

In terms of durability, electric kettles tend to have the upper hand due to their sturdier materials and less exposed parts. Stovetop kettles, however, can still provide years of use if properly cared for and maintained.

Ultimately, the choice of material will depend on your personal preferences, as well as factors like budget and design.

Aesthetics and Design Choices

Electric kettles come in a wide variety of designs and colours, offering options to suit any kitchen decor. From sleek stainless steel models to elegant borosilicate glass or gooseneck kettles, there's an electric kettle to match your personal style.

In contrast, stovetop kettles often feature a more traditional and simplistic design. While their classic look can be appealing to some, they may not offer the same level of variety and customization as electric kettles. However, the timeless charm of a whistling stovetop kettle holds a special place in the hearts of many coffee enthusiasts.

Practicality and Convenience

When it comes to practicality and convenience, electric kettles undoubtedly reign supreme. Their fast boiling times and easy-to-use features make them a popular choice for many households. Electric kettles often come with added benefits like easy filling and a cordless design, making them even more convenient to use on a daily basis.

Stovetop kettles, while charming in their simplicity, can be less practical and convenient due to their slower boiling times and reliance on an external heat source. However, for those who enjoy the ritual of making coffee using a stovetop kettle, the process can be a comforting and nostalgic part of their daily routine.

Top Recommendations for Electric Kettles

When it comes to choosing a new electric kettle for your coffee brewing needs, the Fellow Stagg EKG Electric Pour-Over Electric Kettle stands out as an exceptional option. This kettle is designed with coffee enthusiasts in mind, offering a range of features that elevate the brewing experience.

One of the key advantages of the Stagg EKG is its precise temperature control. With variable temperature settings, you have the ability to choose the perfect water temperature for your preferred coffee brewing method. This level of control is crucial for achieving optimal flavour extraction, particularly in delicate pour-over methods, to brew a cup of coffee with nuanced flavours and aromas.

This kettle also comes equipped with a built-in brew stopwatch. This feature allows you to time your coffee brewing process with accuracy. Whether you're following a specific recipe or experimenting with different brewing techniques, having a reliable timer ensures consistency and precision in your brew. It enables you to achieve the desired extraction times, which can significantly impact the taste and quality of your coffee.

Beyond its functional features, the Stagg EKG kettle boasts a sleek and stylish design. It adds a touch of elegance to your coffee setup, complementing the aesthetics of your kitchen or brewing station with their minimalistic look, and are available in black or white. The Stagg EKG has a gorgeous gooseneck, which achieves a timeless look while also helping you control your pour and brew a more balanced cup of coffee.

Top Recommendations for Stovetop Kettles

The Hario V60 Buono Drip Kettle is a fantastic choice for those in search of a new stovetop or gas kettle, particularly if you love making coffee. This kettle stands out for several reasons. First and foremost, its design is centred around precision pouring, which is crucial for pour-over coffee brewing methods like the V60. The Buono Drip Kettle's slim spout ensures a steady and controlled flow of water, allowing you to achieve an even extraction and fully explore the flavours of your coffee grounds.

Additionally, the kettle is crafted from high-quality materials, including stainless steel, ensuring durability and heat retention. Its ergonomic handle provides a comfortable grip, allowing for easy and precise pouring. The Buono Drip Kettle's elegant design also adds a touch of sophistication to your brewing setup, making it visually appealing as well as practical.

While there are many stovetop kettles available on the market, the Hario V60 Buono Drip Kettle stands out as a top choice for those seeking a balance of style, durability, and quality craftsmanship in their stovetop kettle.


The choice between an electric and a stovetop kettle ultimately comes down to your personal preferences and needs. Electric kettles like the Fellow Stagg EKG Electric Pour-Over offer speed, convenience, and safety features that make them a popular choice for many households. On the other hand, stovetop kettles like the Hario V60 Buono Drip Kettle provide a nostalgic and traditional experience that some may find comforting and enjoyable.

If you're in the market for quality appliances that enhance your morning coffee experience, you're in the right place! Explore our full kettle range alongside our other coffee equipment, including scales, grinders, and pour-over coffee brewers, as well as our delicious specialty beans.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a stove top kettle better than an electric kettle?

Ultimately, it depends on your preference. A stovetop kettle gives you more control and precision over the boiling temperature. But an electric kettle is much faster and easier to use.

Both have their pros and cons, so it's up to you to decide which is best for you.

Is it cheaper to use an electric kettle or electric stove?

Electric kettles are the more cost effective option for heating water, since they are about 80 percent efficient while an induction stove or hot plate is only about 70 percent efficient.

So if you're looking to save money when heating water, an electric kettle is the way to go!

Is an electric or stove top kettle better for brewing coffee?

Both electric and stovetop kettles can be suitable for brewing coffee, but electric kettles offer advantages such as precise temperature control and convenience, making them a popular choice among coffee enthusiasts.

Stovetop kettles, on the other hand, can provide a more traditional and visually engaging brewing experience but may lack some of the temperature control features found in electric kettles.